Showing posts with label Theo Epstein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theo Epstein. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Chris Carpenter for Theo? That's a good deal.

The Cubs have finally announced the compensation deal for stealing Theo Epstein today.  Cubs minor league fireballer, Chris Carpenter, will be heading to the Red Sox along with a player to be named later.  The Cubs are to receive a player to be named later as well.

A lot of people really like Carpenter.  He wowed many of us last year by hitting triple digits on a number of occasions in his few appearances with the Cubs last season.

For a while, the Cubs tried to use Carpenter as a starting pitcher, but moved him back to the bullpen last year.  He's a great talent that may pan out to be a big league closer some day if he is able to find some control on that fastball.

In the end, the Cubs had to give up a minor league relief pitcher to get Theo.  That's a damn good deal.  No starting pitcher or position player and no top of the line prospect...there should be no reason to complain about that.

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Some thoughts on the Theo compensation


We should expect Bud Selig (or Bid Selif if you are theChicago Tribune) to rule on the compensation package that the Cubs will have to surrender for ‘stealing’ Theo Epstein from the Red Sox.

Currently the thought is that the Cubs will have to give up a top prospect with Trey McNutt or Josh Vitters as possible targets.

The truth is I’m not sure if anyone really does know how Selig will rule on this.  In fact, there are a number of facts that on both sides of this issue that could be used to support a substantial compensation and to support very little compensation.

Why the Cubs will pay substantial compensation:
  1. Recently, precedent with the Ozzie Guillen compensation between the White Sox and Marlins was relatively substantial…two higher prospects.
  2. Bud Selig will likely want to try to make a statement that top executives under contract can’t just hope from one organization to another.
  3. Theo Epstein’s overall stature in the baseball community.  He’s regarded as one of the top baseball executives.
  4.  Red Sox owner John Henry and Bud Selig are good buddies and Selig has done a number of favors for Henry topped off by letting him sell the Marlins to another owner (orphaning the Expos) and letting him purchase the Red Sox even as other bidders offered more money.


Why the Cubs will not pay substantial compensation:
  1. In 1994 the Cubs only had to give up 2 low level prospects to take Andy McPhail away from the Twins.  MacPhail was the Twins GM and he was promoted to team President when he joined the Cubs…similar to the situation with Theo. 
  2. Theo was promoted in the process of going to the Cubs.  For the most part, teams in baseball (and most other sports) will not require significant compensation when a guy leaves to take a job with a higher title.
  3. Theo was going to leave after the 2012 season and might have even resigned his position before the 2012 season since much of the rest of the Red Sox organization was in a time of transition.
  4. There isn’t a large problem with team executives bolting from one organization to another.  There is no reason to do anything drastic here to try to prevent a problem from growing. 
  5.  It’s not good business practice for baseball to try to prevent an executive from taking a job with more responsibility or getting a promotion. 
  6. While Guillen did get the White Sox a good haul, the job with the Marlins wasn’t a promotion for Guillen.  He has the same job now as he did with the White Sox. 

My gut feeling on the matter is that the Cubs will likely give up Trey McNutt in the deal.  The Red Sox have made it known they want pitching and initially wanted Matt Garza as compensation.  McNutt is the best pitching prospect in the Cubs system right now and I expect Selig will favor the Red Sox a bit more in this deal just because of his previous dealings with John Henry. 

Expect a ruling on this before the end of the week.  

Saturday, December 17, 2011

Avoid being used as a pawn by Scott Boras

It is my firm belief that the Cubs are not seriously trying to acquire Prince Fielder.

Every day there is a new report that contradicts a report from the previous day in regards to the Cubs interest in the first baseman.

This isn't too different from what happened 10 years ago when another Scott Boras client, Alex Rodriguez was a free agent. The Yankees were rumored to have been interested in the shortstop back in 2001. As we all know, A-Rod signed with the Rangers for a record $252 million. Afterwards it was discovered that the Yankees were not interested and it was generally accepted that the Yankees rumors were not actually true.

In 2001, Scott Boras needed the Yankees to be involved in the "sweepstakes" in order to get A-Rod the amount of money and years that he wanted.

Prince Fielder is Boras's biggest free agent client this year (and probably his biggest client period in talent and stature). We know for a fact that big spending teams like the Phillies, Yankees and Red Sox have absolutely no interest in Fielder, but the Cubs have a vacancy at first base and they have money to spend. It's very easy to assume that the Cubs might be interested in getting Prince even if he comes at an astronomical price tag.

But the Cubs aren't spending this year. Hoyer and Epstein have taken over this club and every move to this point has appeared to be aimed at cheap, short term solutions to holes that the team has. Matt Garza is on the trading block. David DeJesus and Ian Stewart have been acquired. This team isn't being built like Epstein's old team, the Red Sox. It's actually being assembled in a fashion more like Hoyer's former team, the Padres.

So could these rumors be legit? I don't think so for five reasons:

First, the Cubs, in their moves so far this year, appear for the first time in my lifetime, to be truly rebuilding. Shedding of high priced contracts and stocking up on prospects has been the theme that Jed and Theo have laid out to everyone. This is a team that is looking to make a splash in 2 years, not now.

Second, every statement out of the mouths of the Cubs management in regards to Fielder has been that the team doesn't have much interest in the 1st baseman. Hoyer said that the winter meetings that the Cubs interest in Fielder was overstated. Just this past week, Dale Sveum said that the team had not talked to the big 1st baseman. At this point, I'd have to take their word for it. We Cubs fans don't quite know exactly how the new Cubs front office strategically handles negotiations like this. It could be a their way of trying to drive down the cost to them if they actually want Fielder, but we don't know that this is how they'd want to do this.

Third, the vastly conflicting reports tells me that there are at least two different sources leaking information. One of these sources in lying. For what purpose would that source lie? Simply, to gain some sort of advantage. For the Cubs to be leaking a lie that they were not interested doesn't give them much of any advantage other than what I mentioned in the previous point, but we don't know if that is how the Cubs work. Scott Boras leaking a lie that the Cubs are very interested is of great advantage to him as it gets the teams that actually are interested (the Mariners, Nationals and Orioles) to believe they need to boost their offers for Fielder.

Fourth, Scott Boras has done this before. See the beginning of this post.

And finally, the 2011 draft. More specifically Dan Vogelbach. The Cubs drafted, in the second round of the 20122 draft, a player that some people consider the next Prince Fielder. He might still be 3 to 5 years off, but if this kid does work out, when he's ready to be a big leaguer, he'll be stuck behind a big fat Prince Fielder 8 year contract. We all know that prospects only work a small percentage of the time, but it seems like it would be weird for the Cubs to sign a player to a huge contract when they potentially have someone within their own system that would provide the same abilities. The Cubs want to develop players from within, so I would expect them to try to do everything they can to develop Vogelbach for a relatively cheap price as opposed to signing Fielder for the GDP of a small country.

********************

In the end, I expect the Cubs to actually go after a different Scott Boras client...Carlos Peña...to play first base. Yes, Peña's batting average continues to be under .230, but he did draw a ton of walks, saw a lot of pitches in each at-bat, and after a slow start, hit a good number of homers last year. On top of that, he was very good at first base (better than I expected), which was saying something considering that every other throw from Starlin Castro was in the dirt.

Peña is exactly what Theo Epstein said he was looking for...good defensively and a hitter that grinds out every at bat.

As a stop gap until someone else is developed, a two year deal for Peña at $24 million doesn't seem like too bad of an option.

Monday, October 24, 2011

Top 10 things we don't want to hear out of Theo Epstein’s mouth tomorrow

10: “Don’t worry, Mike Quade won’t be managing this team next year…because I’ve hired Jim Riggleman to take his place.”

9: "Since I don't know much about this organization, I'm going to let Crane Kenney make most of the major baseball related decisions."

8: "I'll be appearing on "Undercover Boss" later this year."

7: "We're going to move the Cubs to the AL East."

6: “103 years? Really? Holy crap, you guys seriously suck. Get me outta here!"

5: "No more Old style. Sam Adams for everyone."

4: "I've altered the Wrigley Field renovation plans so that a large green wall can be erected out in left field."

3: “I hope you guys don’t have any curses around here…especially ones about billy goats because I’m deathly afraid of billy goats.”

2: “I’m glad to make this change. Since there isn’t really any big pressure to actually win here, I can finally relax a bit.”

1: “Looking at the situation as a whole, I don’t see any real need to change anything here except making Koyie Hill the everyday catcher.”